Broadway Plan versus Vancouver’s Urban Forest: A case study at 310 East 14th Avenue (Council is preparing to further turbocharge the Plan on Dec 11, 2024)


Specimen tree at the corner of East 14th Avenue and Sophia Street (left) and rezoning sign (right)

A specimen tree is a prominent, individual tree noted for its exceptional qualities, often used as a focal point in landscaping or conservation. If approved, a proposed rezoning for a 20-storey tower at East 14th and Sophia Street in Vancouver would have the tree removed as part of the development, which is enabled under the Broadway Plan (adopted in 2022).

Rezoning applications like the one at 310 East 14th Avenue would not only be demolishing existing affordable rental housing, displacing long-time tenants, and driving up the cost of land, but would also result in the loss of precious tree canopy. For further analysis on the rezoning at 310 East 14th, please see our previous post. (The developer is Wall Financial, on behalf of 632668 B.C. Ltd. on title, which is on behalf of Sophia Apartment Holdings Ltd., but the ultimate owners are not publicly known.)

The large specimen tree on the subject site gives a lot of character to the neighbourhood as well as serving ecological functions. Vancouver is already deficient in urban tree canopy yet claims to have a goal of becoming the greenest city in the world.

See our portal page on the Broadway Plan (https://cityhallwatch.wordpress.com/broadway-plan/). There are currently three petitions challenging the Broadway Plan. A rally of about 500 people was held on November 23 calling for the City to “Pause the Plan.” The City of Vancouver will be considering amendments to the Broadway Plan on Wednesday December 11, 2024 that would further turbocharge the Plan (see this post for what a full build-out would look like).

We’ve created a comparison to show the current condition at East 14th and Sophia below and the tower massing (note a wide angle 24mm lens was used in order to fit in most of the proposed tower massing).

Side by side comparison at Sophia Street and East 14th Avenue. Before & after. The simplified model of the massing of the proposed tower component (just the tower was modelled and not ground level planters, ramps and stairs) has been located and tracked into the photo for a comparison of scale. City staff have not provided direct before and after comparisons of this proposal.
Detail of trunk of specimen tree (it appears to be a Himalayan cedar / Cedrus deodara which is planted as an ornamental tree)
Simplified model of 310 East 14th Avenue is in the lower left. This 3D massing model shows a build-out under the proposed Broadway Plan Amendments that go to City Council on December 11, 2024. Council will be looking to remove towers per block limits over part of the plan area, increase height and density over a number of sub-areas, while loosening solar protections for greenspaces and village high streets.
Three storey rental building at 310 East 14th Avenue would be demolished as part of the rezoning proposal for a 20-storey tower and all tenants would be displaced.

ShapeYourCity:https://www.shapeyourcity.ca/310-e-14-ave

Photo taken with a 50mm lens for comparison.



Read more

Posted in Wordpress